Annabella's House of Mozzarella: Authentic Italian Delicacies in East Rutherford

Wow! Everything was over the top! We had 3 different sandwiches all fantastic. We had soup which was delicious. And 2 desserts that were yum yum! Kevin went over and beyond to make sure we were satisfied! 10+

Great early dinner here at 4pm on Tuesday. The Annibellas mozzarella and bread is a great appetizer, but I shouldn't have gotten it! I could only finish half of my Stupid Cupid sandwich. Big portions, that taste good. Plenty of brews and other drinks to choose from.

5 stars! I had a grilled chicken with Mozz, pesto and roasted peppers on a hero. Pro tip order a side of their homemade sauce! I needed a bowl of it alone!!! First I couldn't believe how great the quality of their hero bread was. The highest quality. When I told them about it they said they make it themselves all day! Who does that?? Also the sandwich with the fresh mozz, pesto and red peppers was huge! Enough for or should be enough for 2. The decor of the place inside was nuts and I won't describe it just go for yourselves. This is not a cookie cutter place. Highly recommended would easily go back over and over. I should have taken pictures!!!!!

Fantastic as always. Great intimate atmosphere. Great drinks (mozzarella martini & old fashioned with the frozen fruit). Delicious mozzarella. This visit we enjoyed the Chuck wagon and the snapper- would definitely recommend the Chuck wagon made with flank steak. Thanks to Billy for making our experience supreme by giving us a free concert. We love his business and will continue to support him.

Great place from top to bottom. Nice Italian grocery when you walk in. We came on Friday and there was a live band that ROCKED and got people from ages 20-80 movin and groovin. Our server Amy was great. Very accommodating and answered our questions about certain dishes. Fantastic food and people. The house made mozzarella was . The owner Billy came around and talked to us for a while, very cordial and funny. Grazie mille! Would come back 11/10 times

What a find! Was lucky enough to get in close to closing time. Welcomed with great service, Bartender ‘D’ was terrific. Excellent advice on the menu. I hade the fresh house made mozzarella and tomato salad- very good. Summer fresh tomatoes would send it over the top. Pasta Bella for an entree. It was amazing w/a glass of house Cab. I missed the mozzarella making class by half an hour. I’m from the west coast in town on business. Annabella’s was the meal of the trip. Highly recommended!

We got it delivered to the hotel and it was fantastic! Everything was fresh and delicious. DoorDash forgot our desert and Kevin personally delivered it to us. Overall experience 10/10.

If you’re in the East Rutherford area, Annabella’s House of Mozzarella is a place you don’t want to miss! From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere was so welcoming. We started with the calamari, and it was amazing—crispy, tender, and served with a flavorful tomato sauce that hit the spot. For the main course, the Pollo Campagna was incredible. The chicken was so tender and packed with flavor, and the artichoke sauce made it even better. It was honestly one of the best dishes I’ve had in a while. The live music on Friday night was a perfect touch and really set a fun mood for the evening. Bill, our host, was super friendly and took great care of us, making sure we had everything we needed. If you’re looking for great food, awesome service, and a fun vibe, Annabella’s is definitely worth checking out! Highly recommend it!